My Journey into the Science of Gratitude

In December 2022, I had the privilege of attending the Learning Forward annual conference in Nashville. One of the major highlights of that trip for me was attending a session by Marcia Tate based off her (then) new book, Healthy Teachers, Happy Classrooms. I have since read the book 3 times, and I take something new away from each experience. This April, I will present (for the second time) concepts from her book at our district’s annual conference. And this weekend, I began rereading the books my session is based on to help me prepare (and potentially update) my presentation.
I first shared this information in 2023 and was prepared to share it again last year - until our event was snowed out. (That was a rough day…) In 2023, the session was entirely based on Tate’s work. But last year, I also happened to spend time reading another book that has become one of my annual re-reads: Evolving with Gratitude by Lainie Rowell. That book, in turn, led me to my current re-read: The Gratitude Project. The session I’m currently planning is built primarily from Tate’s work but heavily features the other two books in one of the sections.
Over the past few days, I’ve re-read two of these books (Healthy Teachers and Evolving with Gratitude). It amazes me how I have different take-aways each time I read them, based largely on my current life situation. Here’s what I’m learning (or re-learning) this time around:
Mental Subtraction - strange as it sounds (at least to me), this is a technique to help cultivate gratitude. The premise is fairly straightforward: Think of a positive in your life. Reflect on why it’s so important to you. Then imagine your life without that event or person and reflect on the ripple effects. Why does it work? “We often don’t appreciate what we have until we imagine how different life could have been” (Rowell, pg. 37). I highlighted this concept last year when I first read Evolving with Gratitude, but I didn’t try it until yesterday. It was amazing to me how quickly my mind filled with gratitude not just for the people I originally thought about, but for so many little things I otherwise wouldn’t have stopped to consider!
Sharing Wins & Failures. Have students reflect on their week with two prompts: “Talk about a Failure” and “Talk about a Win.” Each of those prompts were accompanied by some follow-up questions that I really like and want to find a way to incorporate in my classes:
Talk about a Failure
What’s a major fail you had this week?
How did your initial approach to the problem or situation lead you astray?
How has your approach to the problem or situation changed now? How has your thinking shifted?
What is one thing you can take away as a lesson learned from this fail? How can you turn this into a future win?
Talk about a Win
What’s a major win you had this week?
How did your initial approach to the problem or situation lead to your success?
What is one thing you can take away as a lesson learned from this win? How can you apply this lesson to help you find figure successes?
Scheduling Gratitude - This idea is simple: set aside 10 minutes at the beginning of every team meeting to pause and express thanks. I tried this a few times last year and I LOVED it. Did everyone in the meeting also love it? I don’t know…but I sure did! It’s important to leave the expression of gratitude up to each individual - I provided blank notecards for anyone who wanted to write some (and several people did), but sending texts/emails of appreciation or planning ways to express gratitude later that week are also great options.
Handwritten Notes - This one is also simple. Whenever you start to feel overwhelmed or slightly down, handwrite a note of appreciation for someone and then delivering it in person. First of all, handwritten notes take time. And I, for one, truly love receiving them. Second, it's hard to be upset when you're writing about why you appreciate someone - so this practice has positive effects for everyone involved!
Gratitude has kind of become my academic obsession over the past year or so. The book I’ve just started re-reading really dives into the scientific and psychological side of it, and I love geeking out over the concept! Having said that, I want to include a sidenote that I added to my presentation last year. Educators are quick to call out toxic positivity; but this isn't about toxic positivity. It’s not about pretending everything’s okay when the world is in chaos. It’s about reframing how we look at the world, which - in my humble opinion - can give us a pretty significant advantage when it comes time to face that chaos. These quotes sum up my thoughts better than I could:
“Focusing on gratitude and what is working doesn’t mean that we ignore challenges, it just means we choose to build on a foundation of what we have, successes we have experienced, and the strengths of individuals and their contributions” (Rowell, pg. 81).
“I’m not ignoring the threats that may come; I’m appreciating the resources and people that might help me face those threats.” (The Gratitude Project, pg. 75)
“It is vital to make a distinction between feeling grateful and being grateful. We don’t have total control over our emotions. We cannot easily will ourselves to feel grateful, less depressed, or happy. Feelings follow from the way we look at the world, thoughts we have about the way things are, the way things should be, and the distance between these two points. But being grateful is a choice, a prevailing attitude that endures and is relatively immune to the gains and losses that flow in and out of our lives.” (The Gratitude Project, pg. 98)
I find it interesting - but not surprising - that both Marcia Tate and Lainie Rowell's books were published in 2022 while The Gratitude Project was published in September of 2020. Let's be real - we were all still trying to figure out how to get back from the pandemic. Everything was different. And there were a lot of reasons to NOT feel grateful. But it's hard to argue with brain research. Gratitude works...you just have to let it. And this weekend, I've re-learned a few techniques to help my students (and myself!) make that a priority. I can't wait to see how they help us to grow!



Comments